“Overweight” != unhealthy.

A recent NYTimes article asks whether you can be overweight and still healthy. I want to quickly point out an inherent problem in the use of “overweight” as a measure and a problem with using BMI.

Will Smith. 6'2 and 209 lbs. 15 lbs. "overweight"

“Overweight” is determined by having a BMI over 25, while “obese” is having a BMI over 30. BMI is, however, a flawed measure of healthy fat distribution for certain population groups. A 6′ tall individual has to be 183 lbs. or under to be considered “normal weight”. If you actually see a 6′ tall person who is 184 lbs, there’s no way you would consider him/her anyone close to overweight. Conversely, overweight shorter people benefit from this quirk in BMI.

Randall Mackey (6'0", 185 lbs.)

The reason for this is the way BMI is calculated as mass divided by height squared; it is inversely proportional to the square of the height. So after a certain point, at a constant weight, as height increases the BMI decreases at an exponentially slower rate (imagine the 1/x² graph). Thus, taller people have a higher BMI than their body fat would suggest. Additionally, since muscle weighs more than fat, a healthy individual with a lot of muscle mass can be overweight while an individual with fat instead could have a healthy/healthier BMI.

So the conclusions from studies based on BMI should be taken with those facts in mind. I think ideally a better measure for fat content should be created that will be more complicated, but more accurate, than the oversimplified BMI. Some people advocate for waist circumference, but it’s a bit naive to create a measure that can be manipulated at will by a patient. Normal ranges of height/weight could be calculated demographically, like a the growth curves we have in pediatrics clinics, instead of just using a formula that attempts to capture a trend. This might not solve for muscle mass, but would solve for the graphical irregularities you get from BMI.


2 thoughts on ““Overweight” != unhealthy.

  1. I agree that BMI has its limits as a measurement. We use BMI because it is very easy to calculate (anyone with a scale can do it at home). It’s a good way to give people a ballpark figure of whether or not they’re overweight. Obviously, more complex tests can better analyze percentages of body fat, but such measurements are far harder to take.

    Given the scope of obesity in this country, nitpicking whether BMI might accidentally shift a few people into “obese” doesn’t seem like too much of a problem. Additionally, as an exactly 6’0 individual, I can definitely say that I’m carrying a bit of a gut when I weigh 184 pounds. Is it particularly unhealthy? Is it because I don’t have a ton of muscle mass? Is it really a problem that it might make me want to hit the gym?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s